This time of year, leadership teams make a quiet agreement.
It usually happens near the end of a long meeting. Someone raises the question that has been circling for months: the program that isn't performing, the partnership that needs a decision, the funding model that's starting to strain. Heads nod.
Then someone says, "Let's table this until after the holidays."
Sometimes that's exactly the right call. Not every question needs an answer before the year ends, and teams that protect their rest tend to make better decisions when they return.
But some questions don't wait well.
Delay isn't neutral. While the decision sits, the organization keeps moving, and it starts adapting around the absence of a choice.
Budgets get built.
Workarounds become habits.
People quietly draw their own conclusions about what leadership really thinks matters.
So how do you tell the difference? In my experience, a decision probably can't wait if one or more of these is true.
1. It has appeared on more than one agenda
The first time an issue comes up, it's information. The third time, it's a pattern.
When the same question keeps returning with no resolution, the team isn't still gathering facts. It's usually avoiding the cost of the answer. Every return trip makes the question heavier, because now it carries the original issue and the credibility of a team that hasn't addressed it.
2. The budget is about to lock in last year's assumptions
Most organizations finalize their resource decisions in the first quarter. If a strategic question is unresolved when that happens, the budget answers it for you, usually by funding the past.
That's why strategy needs to come before budget, not after it. A decision deferred to January often means a decision deferred well into next year.
3. Someone is about to ask for direction you don't have
A December board meeting. A major funder conversation. A new leader starting in the first quarter. These moments ask the leadership team to speak with one voice about where the organization is going.
If the honest answer is "we're still figuring that out," that's useful to know now rather than in the room. Boards and funders can handle a clear question. What starts to erode their confidence is a team that still doesn’t have an answer to that question the second time its asked.
4. People are already working around the gap
Look for the quiet signs: departments building their own priorities, staff asking the same question in different ways, talented people waiting to see which way things will go before they commit their energy.
When the organization starts compensating for a missing decision, the decision has already been made. It's just being made by default, in a dozen places at once, by people who don't have the full picture.
What the leaders who don't wait have in common
The organizations I see making room for these decisions in December aren't doing it because they have everything figured out. Quite the opposite. Something has shifted, the old assumptions aren't holding, and they've recognized that continuing to circle the wagons isn't going to get them anywhere.
And they're certainly not oblivious to the holiday season. Nobody's trying to be the corporate villain in a Hallmark movie, demanding everyone report back to the office on Christmas Eve. (We all know how that story ends.)
These leaders have full calendars, families, holiday plans, and people who need a break. They know all of that.
They've simply decided that this particular conversation matters enough to make room for it now.
They may not walk into January with every answer. But they can enter the new year having faced the questions that matter, rather than carrying another month of uncertainty about whether anyone is willing to address them.
A simple test before the holidays
Before your team scatters for the season, ask one question together:
"What are we planning to 'get to in January' that we already know matters?"
If the answer touches one or more of the signs above, it may be worth a conversation now, even a short one, to name the decision, agree on who owns it, and set a date to resolve it.
When the question is bigger than one meeting
Some strategic questions can't be resolved by adding another agenda item. They touch the organization's direction, competing priorities, resources, and the decisions leaders need to make together.
That's where I work with leadership teams through Shepherd + CO's strategic planning and facilitation. We create the space to see the whole picture, work through the difficult choices, and establish a shared direction for what comes next.
If your organization is at that kind of turning point.
Cassandra Shepard is the founder of Shepherd + CO, a boutique strategic advisory firm. She works with senior leaders navigating the intersection of enterprise strategy and advanced leadership. www.cassandrashepard.com